A memo that was accidently posted on the Nassau County District Attorney’s office website before being removed provides a new version of events that led to the friendly fire killing of , who was assigned to the Bureau of ATF's in Melville, during an of in Seaford on New Year's Eve.
The document, which was provided to Patch, contained details given by a pharmacist at the store that said retired Nassau County police Lt. Christopher Geraghty of Woodbury shot once without warning during a skirmish on the ground between Capano and the robbery suspect James McGoey of Hampton Bays. The shot proceeded to strike and kill Capano, a Massapequa resident and who was at pharmacy picking up cancer medication for his father.
The pharmacist’s statement in the memo differs from what Geraghty’s attorney Brian Davis told the Associated Press last month about his client shooting Capano as he and the suspect struggled for control of a weapon while unsure who was “the bad guy.” A redacted version of the memo with the names of those involved blocked out was posted Wednesday on the 1010 WINS Radio website and can be found by clicking here.
In response to the memo, Davis told Newsday that witnesses having differing accounts of what happened in a crime are not unusual.
"In the heat of battle, people see different things in different ways," Davis said.
The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) issued a statment last month blaming the shooting death of Capano on a “career criminal who chose to resume his life of crime” on that fateful New Year’s Eve afternoon.
Prior to being gunned down during the New Year’s Eve Seaford armed robbery, Capano was in his 24th year as an ATF agent and assigned to the New York Field Division’s Long Island Field Office in Melville. He was a member of the Federal Law Enforcement Officers Association and the International Association of Bomb Technicians and Investigators (IABTI) who had had taught U.S. military and local forces in Afghanistan and Iraq how to investigate blasts.