Who Cares about Suburban Public Schools?
CHARLOTTE, N.C.—In a rousing speech to the cheering New York Democratic delegation here Thursday, Gov. Andrew Cuomo called New York the “progressive capital of the nation.”
Syracuse Mayor Stephanie Miner introduced Cuomo by citing a Siena Poll that found 56 percent of New Yorkers believe the state is going in the right direction.
In spelling out the state’s accomplishments, Cuomo spoke about education, saying: “We know we can improve education by educating all children. We know we can improve education by performance standards and an (teacher) evaluation system. We just did that in New York.”
And he energized the delegates and guests by posing several rhetorical questions: “Do you believe when I invest in your child’s education, I invest in my child’s education? Do you believe education is the ladder to opportunity? Do you believe college loans have to be affordable?”
After the speech, I spoke with Southampton Town Councilwoman Bridget Fleming, the Democratic candidate for New York State Senate against incumbent Republican Sen. Kenneth LaValle. Fleming was attending her first convention with her 9-year-old-son, Jai, who attends .
“Gov. Cuomo has outlined the blueprint for prosperity in New York State, and I’m proud to be here,” she said. “But the governor didn’t mention the need to reform the state aid formula [for public schools]. One of the reasons I’m running as a mother of a fourth grader is to change that. We give the state more tax dollars than we get back. I’m here to represent Long Island and the educational needs of Long Island, which are completely distinct from New York City or upstate. Long Island can no longer continue to be a cash cow for the rest of the state.”
Fleming said she would like to change the state aid formula “so it doesn’t punish people who pay high property taxes but don’t have much disposable income. We need to reduce tax assessments for purposes of the formula. When aid to education is reduced, it shifts the burden to the taxpayer and hurts the local economy.”
Lawrence C. Levy, the executive dean of the National Center for Suburban Studies at Hofstra University in Hempstead, N.Y., was at both the Republican and Democratic conventions and we chatted about how neither party is currently talking about addressing the needs of suburban schools.
“If the Republicans and Democrats were to score points with swing voters in the suburbs, they should start talking about what they can do for suburban schools,” Levy said. “Both parties are assuming it’s still the '60s or '70s when suburban schools didn’t need help. It’s one thing to leave the content of curriculum to the states, but it’s another to leave the entire burden of funding. The suburbs need a lot more help and only the federal government has deep pockets.”
Obama’s Trouble With Young People
Characterizing the 2012 election as one of the closest in recent history, on Tuesday Independent Pollster John Zogby reviewed the difficulties President Barack Obama faces in attracting young voters in the 2012 election. He noted that Obama, who received the support of young people in record numbers in 2008, is having trouble with the 18- to 29-year-old constituency this year. He said that young people, who he characterized as “America’s first global citizens,” comprised 19 percent of the total vote last time, and that in 2008 they were “filled with hope and optimism.”
He noted that this year a subset of this group, which he referred to as CEMGA — College Educated Not Going Anywhere — because of the recession, don’t trust anyone. Zogby said his poll indicated that at the present time, there is a small group of young people — 10 percent — who say they may vote for Gary Johnson, a libertarian.
Zogby said also that he found a growing sense of libertarianism among young people, as well as “a sense of distrust about the government, the debt, the leadership.”
I was really shocked, thought he understood America better than Obama, but I was wrong...
Where are these teachers out on disability for years? This is one I have never heard of before? What districts are you referring too? Is this a true statement? I
I would even take 1-9 odds! Leave LI while you can!
it's a broken system with no improvement worth while to speak of. A total overhaul is necessary starting w/ reopening teacher contracts. Our legislators are both too patronized and unconcerned. They continue to wait us out until outcry quiets down then lay back and start promising again w/o anything accomplished. Only answer is.......... Vote out all incumbents! We need Wisconsin, Jersey style leadership!
When we place SPorts and after school activites ABOVE education, when parents scream moan, protest unite when thier kids SPORt program gets cut then parents are sending a clear and loud message to their boards and AMdinstrators. DO NOT TOUCH our WANTs, cut the hell out of our educational needs but do not go anywhere NEAR our after school activites. YOU, set the precedent You establish the pecking order of priorities. No one goes crazy if a educational cuts are made but the WORLD STOPS and people get beserk when a sports program is cut. Go figure why educational funding is screwed up. I would wager most parents would pick sports over ACT/SAT courses or Sports over special ed, or sports over ART . NYS mandates that we legally provide a sound basic education with our tax dollars. THATS IT. THat doesnt include ALL the EXTRAS that add up significantly and in some cases superceed educational departmental budgets. I would gladly pay the taxes i am now to guarantee every child regardless of ability receives a quality education BUT i refuse to pay these taxes when the FOCUS is NOT on education but on expending monies for after school activites on all levels. Dont cry about your taxes becaseu you decided what your priorites are and it isnt on education its after school activites so we can have a well rounded student. well how well rounded will they be when their on a winnning football team and cant make it into college because their SAT/ACT scores SUCK.
At the service academies, participation in sports, either interscholastic or intramural, is mandatory, as is rote memorization of General MacArthur's famous "On the fields of friendly strife...." quote. Pay-to-play would indeed be a "foreign" concept in our military schools. In years gone by, when failed school budget led to "austerity", it was mandated by the state that sports be cut, period. In recent times, when "austerity" was replaced by the more euphamistic "contingent budget", the state stipulated that sports may be considered to be an ordinary contingent expense, and continued in a contingent budget at the board's discretion in the event of a failed regular budget. Of course, proper budgetary discipline and balance, categorical spending limits, as well as the new 2% Tax Levy Cap have to observed in maintaining the sports program in a contingent budget.
Music and Art are part of the Core curriculm if i am not mistaken and a minimum of instruction in the fine arts must be met. Well rounded is not defined by AFTER SCHOOL activites /Sports. There are plenty of students who are well rounded who dont participate in sports, they do community service, belong to community organizations. volunteer, etc. Participating in SCHOOL Sports does not define Well rounded. That is a myth- go ask ANY college counselor or admissions officer -
You have correctly assessed the decades-old method of funding public education in NY. Your direct support for your local school district is through your school property taxes. The State Aid that all schools get comes from the income taxes, sales taxes, gasoline taxes, alcohol and tobacco taxes, vehicle registration and drivers license fees, and lottery money that is shared across the state by a fairly stable and predictable formula. Two lawsuits had been decided by the highest court in NY State (Levittown, and REFIT). In both cases the Court of Appeals held that although school funding may not be "fair", it is not unconstitutional, unless it results in schools being unable to provide a sound, basic education. None of the 35 REFIT districts could claim they were unable to provied a sound, basic education when asked directly by the court. A third party, Campaign for Fiscal Equity (CFE), filed a third suit and said that NY City schools were not able to provide a sound, basic education to many children because of the state aid formula. The City agreed. CFE won several billion dollars for NY City schools. Here's the rub. NYC receives about $1 back from the state in aid for every $1 they send to Albany in taxes!